;

Shang Guan Pei Yin: Is Direct Resource or Indirect Resource Better?

Shang Guan Pei Yin, the Hurting Officer supported and checked by the Resource stars, is often a good setup. But if you are asking whether it works better with Direct Resource or Indirect Resource, the answer depends on one basic Five Elements rule.

The Rule Behind the Pattern

Many people see Shang Guan Pei Yin and assume the combination is good. In general, it can be. But you still have to ask what kind of Resource star is doing the work.

The key question is simple: when one element controls another, does same-yin-yang control work with more force, or does opposite-yin-yang control work with more force? For example, does Bing, a yang-fire stem, control Geng, a yang-metal stem, more strongly, or does Ding, a yin-fire stem, control Geng more strongly?

The answer is Bing. Same-yin-yang control is the more efficient form of control.

Why Direct Resource Usually Fits Better

Take a person with Ji, a yin-earth stem, as the Day Master. For this person, Geng is Shang Guan, the Hurting Officer, meaning sharp, forceful expression. Bing and Ding are both Resource stars for Ji.

Now look at the mechanics. Bing and Geng are both yang, so Bing controls Geng through same-yin-yang control. For a Ji-earth person, Bing is Direct Resource. Ding is Indirect Resource.

So in this example, Direct Resource can check the Hurting Officer more effectively than Indirect Resource can. That is why, in general, when the Hurting Officer is unfavorable, Shang Guan Pei Yin works better with Direct Resource. It can restrain the Hurting Officer more cleanly and help balance the Five Elements strength across the whole chart.

So the short answer is: Shang Guan Pei Yin is often a good match, and Direct Resource is generally the more suitable Resource star for this job.

Chart yourself at guanweibazi.com/paipan.